Start with Our Diamond Quiz
Expertise you can trust: Brilliant Earth is known for its award-winning jewelry designs and seamless, innovative shopping experience. This Brilliant Earth metal guide compares platinum and gold's price, durability, weight, and other key characteristics to help you choose the best option. All Brilliant Earth guides are meticulously researched and reviewed by our certified gemologists, content, editorial, and brand teams before publication to ensure industry-leading excellence and accuracy.
Is Platinum Better Than Gold?
When comparing platinum and gold, neither metal is objectively “better” for your engagement ring, wedding ring, or fine jewelry. Each has unique qualities that make it well suited for different lifestyles, styles, and budgets. The right choice depends on your personal preferences and priorities.
Platinum
Platinum stands out for its exceptional purity and durability. Typically containing 90-95% pure platinum, this naturally white metal maintains its color without additional plating. Its density creates a substantial feel, while its hypoallergenic properties make it ideal for sensitive skin. Over time, platinum develops a soft patina that many consider elegant, though it can be polished to restore its original shine.
Yellow Gold
Yellow gold offers timeless warmth and enduring appeal. Made from pure gold alloyed with silver and copper, it comes in a range of karats such as 10K, 14K, and 18K. Its malleability allows jewelers to create intricate details, and its rich hue complements a wide variety of gemstones and skin tones.
White Gold
White gold provides a bright, platinum-like appearance at a more accessible price point. It is crafted by alloying gold with metals like palladium or nickel, then plated with rhodium for a reflective finish. While it may require periodic re-plating to maintain its brilliance, many appreciate it as a balance between durability and affordability. Like yellow gold, white gold is offered in a range of karats.
Rose Gold
Rose gold stands out with its romantic pink hue, created by blending gold with copper and sometimes silver. Available in various karats, the copper content makes it slightly more durable than yellow gold, while its warm color has a vintage-inspired appeal that has become increasingly popular in engagement rings and wedding bands.
While neither metal is objectively better, platinum is the choice for a denser, rarer, and naturally white jewelry metal, offering unmatched durability and hypoallergenic benefits. Gold, on the other hand, is versatile, available in multiple colors, and typically more affordable. White gold mimics platinum’s look at a lower price, while yellow and rose gold offer warm, distinctive alternatives.
In this guide, we’ll break down these differences in detail to help you decide whether platinum or gold is a better choice for your jewelry.
Gold vs. Platinum Comparison
Metal | Composition | Appearance | Weight | Durability | Maintenance | Price | Hypoallergenic Properties |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Platinum | 90-95% pure platinum | Lustrous silvery-white metal | Heaviest; significantly denser than gold | Highly durable | Develops patina; no replating needed | Highest price point | Excellent; highly hypoallergenic |
Yellow Gold | Gold alloyed with copper and silver | Warm yellow color | Lighter than platinum | Good durability | Minimal maintenance; occasional polishing | Varies by karat; generally less than platinum | Moderate; higher karats are more hypoallergenic |
White Gold | Gold alloyed with white metals and rhodium plated | Bright white color when freshly plated | Same weight as yellow gold | Good durability; rhodium plating can wear | May require replating every 1-3 years | Varies by karat; generally less than platinum | Low to moderate; may contain nickel allergens |
Rose Gold | Gold alloyed with copper | Blush pink tone | Same weight as other gold alloys | Highly durable due to copper content | Minimal maintenance; no plating to wear off | Varies by karat; generally less than platinum | Moderate; copper content may cause reactions in some |
Platinum vs. Gold Jewelry
Composition
Platinum: Platinum jewelry typically contains 90-95% platinum, making it denser and more pure than gold alloys.
Yellow Gold: Usually 14K (58.3% gold) or 18K (75% gold), mixed with silver and copper.
White Gold: Made by combining gold with white alloys like palladium or nickel, then rhodium-plated for brightness.
Rose Gold: Created by mixing gold with copper.
Appearance
Platinum: Naturally white and does not require plating. Retains color permanently.
Yellow Gold: Distinctive yellow hue, traditional and timeless.
White Gold: Brilliant white finish due to rhodium plating. Without maintenance, may show a warmer undertone.
Rose Gold: Ranges from soft blush to deep pink depending on copper content.
Weight
Platinum: Denser and heavier than gold, giving jewelry a substantial feel.
Yellow Gold: Lighter than platinum, comfortable for daily wear.
White Gold: Similar in weight to yellow gold.
Rose Gold: Comparable to yellow and white gold in weight.
Durability
Platinum: Highly durable, resists wear and tear.
Yellow Gold: Good durability; softer at higher karats.
White Gold: Good durability; softer at higher karats; rhodium plating can wear off.
Rose Gold: Highly durable, copper makes it more durable than yellow gold.
Maintenance
Platinum: Retains white color naturally, develops a patina that can be polished if desired.
Yellow Gold: Scratches may need polishing; retains color naturally.
White Gold: May need rhodium re-plating every few years.
Rose Gold: Requires minimal upkeep; retains its color.
Price
Platinum: Generally more expensive than gold due to rarity and density.
Yellow Gold: Less expensive than platinum, with price varying by karat.
White Gold: More affordable than platinum but may require periodic upkeep.
Rose Gold: Similar in price to yellow gold.
Hypoallergenic Properties
Platinum: Naturally hypoallergenic, ideal for sensitive skin.
Yellow Gold: Higher karats are hypoallergenic; alloys may irritate at lower karats.
White Gold: Nickel alloys may cause reactions; palladium blends are better for sensitive skin.
Rose Gold: Contains copper, which may cause irritation in sensitive wearers.
Difference Between Gold and Platinum
While both precious metals, gold and platinum have a few key differences. The primary being:
Platinum is a naturally white metal that maintains its color permanently, while gold must be alloyed to achieve different colors. Platinum is significantly denser, creating heavier jewelry with a more substantial feel. Platinum's remarkable strength makes it an excellent choice for securing diamonds and other precious stones, providing unmatched protection for your valuable gemstones.
Gold offers greater versatility in color options and karat weights, allowing more price flexibility. Gold jewelry typically requires different maintenance depending on the specific alloy — white gold may need periodic replating, while yellow and rose gold maintain their appearance with simple cleaning and occasional polishing. Gold is also lighter than platinum, making it more comfortable for those who prefer a less weighty ring.
Bottom Line: Is Gold or Platinum Better?
The choice between gold and platinum depends entirely on your specific needs, preferences, and budget considerations.
- For engagement rings, platinum offers excellent security for valuable gemstones due to its strength and durability. Its white color enhances diamond brilliance, and its hypoallergenic properties ensure comfort for a lifetime of daily wear. Alternatives include white gold (similar appearance at lower initial cost), yellow gold (timeless classic), and rose gold (romantic, distinctive option that complements many skin tones). Budget-conscious couples might prefer 14K or 18K gold, while those with metal sensitivities may invest in platinum.
- For wedding bands, we recommend choosing the same metal as your engagement ring. While mixed metal styles can be appealing, different metals have varying hardness levels. When dissimilar metals touch daily (as engagement and wedding rings typically do), the harder metal scratches and wears down the softer one, causing visible damage and premature wear.
- For everyday jewelry pieces, consider how the metal's properties align with your lifestyle. Active individuals might appreciate platinum’s durability, while those seeking variety at different price points might prefer the options available in white and yellow gold's various karats.
A general rule of thumb is that platinum is ideal for those seeking durability and purity, while gold is perfect for variety and affordability. Ultimately, both metals represent excellent choices for fine jewelry. The "better" option is the one that aligns with your personal preferences, practical needs, and budget considerations.
Platinum vs. Gold FAQ
Is platinum more expensive than gold?
Yes, platinum is typically more expensive than gold due to its rarity, density, and difficult workability. While raw material prices fluctuate, platinum jewelry almost always costs more than gold jewelry of similar design due to rarity and greater metal weight.
Is platinum stronger than gold?
Platinum is not necessarily stronger than gold. Certain gold alloys, particularly those used in 14K and 10K jewelry, can be harder and more scratch-resistant than platinum. Platinum's strength lies in its ability to bend without breaking and maintain its structural integrity over decades of wear.
Is platinum heavier than gold?
Yes, platinum is denser and heavier than pure gold and even more so compared to gold alloys. An identical ring design will weigh significantly more in platinum than in gold. This substantial weight is part of platinum's luxury appeal and contributes to its secure setting of gemstones.
Is platinum harder than gold?
No, platinum is not harder than gold in terms of scratch resistance, but it is more durable. While platinum may show surface scratches, it maintains its weight and structural integrity better than gold over long periods of wear.
Why is platinum more expensive than gold?
Platinum is more expensive than gold because it is rarer, denser, and requires more metal in each piece, making it a more costly metal.
Does platinum scratch easier than gold?
Yes, platinum can show surface marks more readily than some gold alloys, particularly 14K gold. However, platinum's remarkable strength makes it an excellent choice for securing diamonds and other precious stones, providing unmatched protection for your valuable gemstones.
Is platinum more durable than gold?
Yes, platinum is more durable overall and an excellent choice for long-term wear. Platinum offers superior long-term durability despite showing surface scratches more readily. Unlike gold, platinum doesn't thin over decades of wear, maintains its structural integrity better, and secures gemstones more reliably over time. For lifetime jewelry pieces, platinum typically outlasts gold in retaining its overall form and function.
Why is platinum jewelry more expensive than gold?
Platinum jewelry is more expensive than gold because of its higher density, rarity, and purity. These characteristics make platinum jewelry more costly to craft and purchase.
Should I choose a platinum or gold engagement ring?
Choose platinum if you prioritize long-term durability, security for valuable diamonds, naturally white color that enhances diamond brilliance, and hypoallergenic properties. Choose gold if you prefer more color options (yellow, rose, or white), want more flexibility in your budget with different karat options, or prefer jewelry that maintains a polished appearance with less visible patina development.
Is platinum lighter than gold?
No, platinum is significantly heavier than gold. A platinum ring will feel substantially heavier than an identical ring made of gold, contributing to platinum's luxury feel.
